Skip to content

Digital Psychology

United in Distrust

Four in five Germans think their country is divided. First results from around 2.5 million YouTube comments: left and right share their distrust of the media and of politics. They part ways over who is to blame.

Jonas Höttler5 min read

The short version

  1. By feeling, the country is divided. More than 81 percent of Germans perceive society that way. In long-run data on attitudes the rift is hard to find.
  2. A few write a lot. The most active one percent of accounts writes 19 percent of all comments; 59 percent of accounts write exactly once.
  3. The echo chamber is only half there. 82 percent of accounts stay with one channel. But the rest deliver almost half of the comments and write across the camps.
  4. Left and right share their distrust. 11 of 49 recurring claims appear about equally often in both camps. They part ways over who is to blame.

In a 2025 survey by the Mercator Forum Migration and Democracy, more than 81 percent of Germans perceive society as divided. The sociologists Steffen Mau, Thomas Lux and Linus Westheuser write in "Triggerpunkte", citing a series of studies, that over time there is, for Germany, hardly any evidence of a fundamental ideological polarization.

Both are true at once. Surveys measure what people say about themselves when asked. We wanted to know what they write when nobody asks, and since November we have been counting public comments, by now around 2.5 million, under 21 German YouTube channels. The project is called "Wie gespalten sind wir wirklich?", how divided are we really. How the analysis is built is in a piece of its own: How to Read Millions of Comments.

These are the first results. They are provisional; the collection is still running.

Seven numbers · scroll

1 of 7

MIDEM polarization study, 2025

81%

More than four in five Germans perceive society as divided.

The survey asked for an impression. The next six numbers show what people write.

Own count, as of November 17, 2026

about 2.5 m

public comments under 21 German YouTube channels.

The six on the left are compared with the six on the right. The classification is provisional.

834,369 comments from 288,725 accounts

19%

of all comments are written by the most active one percent of accounts.

59 percent of accounts write exactly once. That is similar in every group.

288,725 accounts

82%

of accounts write under one single channel only.

The remaining 17 percent or so deliver almost half of all comments.

Sample of 52,433 comments

11 of 49

recurring claims appear about equally often on the left and the right.

Five of the eleven are about distrust of the media, politics and government.

Sample of 52,433 comments

19 of 21

channels contain the most common shared claim: the media report one-sidedly.

On the left it appears in 1.9 percent of comments, on the right in 2.4 percent.

Sample of 52,433 comments

3.4 times

as often as on the left, the right says migration leads to crime and burdens the welfare state.

With capitalism it is the other way round. Commenters’ claims: not checked, not my opinion.

  1. 81%MIDEM polarization study, 2025. More than four in five Germans perceive society as divided. The survey asked for an impression. The next six numbers show what people write.
  2. about 2.5 mOwn count, as of November 17, 2026. public comments under 21 German YouTube channels. The six on the left are compared with the six on the right. The classification is provisional.
  3. 19%834,369 comments from 288,725 accounts. of all comments are written by the most active one percent of accounts. 59 percent of accounts write exactly once. That is similar in every group.
  4. 82%288,725 accounts. of accounts write under one single channel only. The remaining 17 percent or so deliver almost half of all comments.
  5. 11 of 49Sample of 52,433 comments. recurring claims appear about equally often on the left and the right. Five of the eleven are about distrust of the media, politics and government.
  6. 19 of 21Sample of 52,433 comments. channels contain the most common shared claim: the media report one-sidedly. On the left it appears in 1.9 percent of comments, on the right in 2.4 percent.
  7. 3.4 timesSample of 52,433 comments. as often as on the left, the right says migration leads to crime and burdens the welfare state. With capitalism it is the other way round. Commenters’ claims: not checked, not my opinion.
The same 3,200 points of light draw all seven numbers. One comes from a survey, six from our own count. Everything is provisional: the collection is still running, a language model did the assigning, and the classification of the channels is ours.

Who writes in the comment sections

Anyone who reads comment sections easily takes them for the voice of the audience. Counted, it is a few. Under the long videos of the 21 channels there are 834,369 comments from 288,725 accounts. 59 percent of these accounts wrote exactly once. The most active one percent writes 19 percent of all comments. The 4 percent with more than ten comments write a good third of everything.

That is similar in every group, under left-leaning channels as under right-leaning ones, under political as under non-political ones. It does not tell you which camp you are in.

What you hear in a comment section is volume first.

Echo chamber and filter bubble: what the numbers support

The echo chamber is the best-known explanation for political polarization: people stay among themselves and hear only agreement. The count supports half of that. A good 82 percent of accounts write under one single channel only. But they deliver only a little more than half of the comments. The remaining 17 percent or so write under several channels and deliver almost the other half.

Those who write under several channels are rare and loud. They do not stay in their own camp. Among the pairs of channels with the most shared accounts are pairs across the groups, for instance a right-leaning interview channel and the largest talk format with no recognizable leaning.

Two limits belong here. The overlap shows where accounts write, not what they think. Someone who comments under a right-leaning channel may be disagreeing there. And at the time of this count only a quarter of the approved videos had been collected, the newest of each channel. With more videos the overlap grows. The shares are lower bounds.

What left and right share: the charge of media bias

For the content we analyzed a sample of 52,433 comments. A language model assigned to each comment which recurring claim it contains. 49 claims keep coming back. 11 of them appear about equally often under channels on the left and on the right.

The most common shared one is: the media report one-sidedly and leave out what matters. Under left-leaning channels it appears in 1.9 percent of comments, under right-leaning ones in 2.4 percent. It turns up in 19 of 21 channels.

Claimunder left-leaning channelsunder right-leaning channels
The media report one-sidedly and leave out what matters1.9%2.4%
The government acts against its own citizens0.7%1.0%
Freedom of speech is being restricted0.5%0.7%
The US and the West wage wars for their own interests0.6%0.6%

Five of the eleven shared claims are about distrust of the media, politics and government. They are the commenters' claims. We have not checked them, and they are not our opinion.

Where the camps part ways

The camps part ways over who is to blame.

Claimunder left-leaning channelsunder right-leaning channels
Migration leads to crime and burdens the welfare state0.4%1.3%
The state wastes taxpayers' money0.4%1.3%
Capitalism produces inequality and exploitation1.1%0.1%
The education system is failing0.6%0.1%

Under right-leaning channels the claim about migration appears 3.4 times as often as under left-leaning ones. Under left-leaning channels, in turn, the claim that capitalism produces inequality and exploitation appears a good nine times as often.

Agreed on the problem. At odds over the culprit.

That is how I read the state of things. It is a reading, not a finding.

What these numbers cannot do

  • They are provisional. The collection is still running. The analyses here are from November 13 and 14, 2026, when a quarter of the videos and 1.3 million comments had been collected.
  • A language model did the assigning. Checked by hand, about eight in ten assignments were right. Rankings hold, small differences do not.
  • The classification of the channels is provisional and ours. Six channels each on the left and the right, four with no recognizable leaning, five non-political. A different classification shifts the numbers.
  • Commenters are not the population. They are the loud part of an audience, and YouTube is one platform among many.
  • Whether a comment is hostile is not measured yet. For that, 1,000 comments are being classified by hand.

We study statements, not people. We do not store names, accounts exist only as pseudonyms, and only totals are shown.

What comes next

The count continues. Next come the tone of the comments and how things change over time.

One question to take with you: which claim would you not have expected in both camps?

Sources

  • Mercator Forum Migration and Democracy (MIDEM): Polarisierungsstudie 2025, press release (German). forum-midem.de
  • Steffen Mau, Thomas Lux, Linus Westheuser: "Triggerpunkte. Konsens und Konflikt in der Gegenwartsgesellschaft", excerpt at the Federal Agency for Civic Education (German). bpb.de

Our own numbers. Project "Wie gespalten sind wir wirklich?". Audience: 834,369 comments under long videos of 21 channels, as of November 13, 2026. Claims: sample of 52,433 comments, as of November 14, 2026; share of comments containing the claim, averaged over the channels of a camp.

Related Articles

Jonas Höttler builds software for mid-sized companies with Balane.